November 2024 S M T W T F S 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 Archives
- July 2020
- May 2020
- April 2020
- March 2020
- September 2014
- May 2014
- September 2013
- May 2013
- April 2013
- December 2012
- January 2012
- November 2011
- May 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- September 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- April 2009
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- August 2006
- July 2006
- September 2005
Categories
- A2K3
- anaphylaxis
- Berkman
- Berkman Lunch Series
- Book Reviews
- Conferences
- Developing world
- Diary
- Economics
- Fascinating People
- Film
- health
- Human Rights
- Intellectual Property
- Internet and Democracy
- Law
- Law
- Machine Learning
- Media
- Middle East
- Open Data
- Open Science
- OSTP
- Peer Review
- personal
- Reproducible Research
- Scientific Method
- shameless self-promotion
- Software
- Startups
- Statistics
- Talks
- Technology
- Uncategorized
- Women's rights
Author Archives: Victoria Stodden
Coronavirus diaries – Champaign edition
Illinois locked down relatively early, when a statewide order was issued starting March 21, 2020. Like every lockdown we no longer went to work, restaurants or bars, or visited friends. So after a period of reclusiveness I started going on … Continue reading
Posted in Diary, Fascinating People, health
Leave a comment
Why Distinguishing Experiential and Inferential Computational Knowledge is Important
Scientific communities are grappling with assessing knowledge derived from computational processes: interpretability of machine learning models; generalizability of data science claims; verifiability of computational science. There are two broad categories of “knowing” at play here that distinguish approaches to understanding … Continue reading
Fascinating People: Jason Kohn
Jason Kohn is a documentary maker and director, interviewed most recently by Pure Nonfiction for his more recent release Love Means Zero, about the superstar tennis coach Nick Bollettieri https://purenonfiction.net/83-jason-kohn-love-means-zero/ . The first half of the interview is Kohn’s origin … Continue reading
Posted in Fascinating People, Film
Leave a comment
Paul Meier: Still Saving Millions of Lives
You may never have heard of Paul Meier, but perhaps I can convince you he is one of the 2oth century’s greatest heroes. As I write from my “shelter in place” from the violent COVID-19 pandemic, I’m seeing news stories … Continue reading
Back to blogging?
This blog’s been on hold while I prepared for and (successfully) went through the tenure process. I’d like to start posting again, and I’m shocked that the break has been almost six years..
Posted in Uncategorized
2 Comments
My input for the OSTP RFI on reproducibility
Until Sept 23 2014, the US Office of Science and Technology Policy in the Whitehouse was accepting comments on their “Strategy for American Innovation.” My submitted comments on one part of that RFI, section 11 follow (with minor corrections): “11) … Continue reading
Mistakes by Piketty are OK (even good?)
In an email conversation I tried to make some points about the criticism Piketty has come under for apparently having mistakes in his data. I think the concerns are real but misplaced. Here’s why: There was a point made in … Continue reading
Posted in Uncategorized
Leave a comment
Changes in the Research Process Must Come From the Scientific Community, not Federal Regulation
I wrote this piece as an invited policy article for a major journal but they declined to publish it. It’s still very much a draft and they made some suggestions, but since realistically I won’t be able to get back … Continue reading
Posted in Intellectual Property, Law, Open Data, Open Science, OSTP, Reproducible Research
5 Comments
Peanut allergic reaction
I’ve used this blog for my professional interests thinking that my personal life just isn’t all that interesting. I still don’t think my personal life is of broad interest, but I’m going to describe what happened to me after an … Continue reading
Posted in anaphylaxis, health, personal
2 Comments
What the Reinhart & Rogoff Debacle Really Shows: Verifying Empirical Results Needs to be Routine
There’s been an enormous amount of buzz since a study was released this week questioning the methodology in a published paper. The paper under fire is Reinhart and Rogoff’s “Growth in a Time of Debt” and the firing is being … Continue reading
Posted in Uncategorized
7 Comments
Data access going the way of journal article access? Insist on open data
The discussion around open access to published scientific results, the Open Access movement, is well known. The primary cause of the current situation — journal publishers owning copyright on journal articles and therefore charging for access — stems from authors … Continue reading
Getting Beyond Marketing: Scan and Tell
I love this idea: http://nomoresopa.com/wp/. It’s an Android app that allows you to scan a product’s barcode and it will tell you whether the company that makes the product supports the Stop Online Piracy Act. What’s really happening here is … Continue reading
Posted in Uncategorized
1 Comment
Disrupt science: But not how you’d think
Two recent articles call for an openness revolution in science: one on GigaOM and the other in the Wall Street Journal. But they’ve got it all wrong. These folks are missing that the process of scientific discovery is not, at … Continue reading
Posted in Uncategorized
7 Comments
Don’t expect computer scientists to be on top of every use that’s found for computers, including scientific investigation
Computational scientists need to understand and assert their computational needs, and see that they are met. I just read this excellent interview with Donald Knuth, inventor of TeX and the concept of literate programming, as well as author of the … Continue reading
Posted in Open Science, Reproducible Research, Uncategorized
3 Comments
The nature of science in 2051
Right now scientific questions are chosen for study in a largely autocratic way. Typically grants for research on particular questions come from federal funding agencies, and scientists competitively apply with the money going to the chosen researcher via a peer … Continue reading
Posted in Open Science, Reproducible Research, Statistics
1 Comment
Regulatory steps toward open science and reproducibility: we need a science cloud
This past January Obama signed the America COMPETES Re-authorization Act. It contains two interesting sections that advance the notions of open data and the federal role in supporting online access to scientific archives: 103 and 104, which read in part: … Continue reading
Generalize clinicaltrials.gov and register research hypotheses before analysis
Stanley Young is Director of Bioinformatics at the National Institute for Statistical Sciences, and gave a talk in 2009 on problems in modern scientific research. For example: 1 in 20 NIH-funded studies actually replicates; closed data and opacity; model selection … Continue reading
Smart disclosure of gov data
Imagine a cell phone database that includes terms of service, prices, fees, rates, different calling plans, quality of services, coverage maps etc. – “smart disclosure,” as the term is being used in federal government circles, means how to make data … Continue reading
Posted in Uncategorized
3 Comments
Open Gov and the VA
Peter Levin is CTO of the Dept of Veteran’s Affairs and has a take on open gov tailored to his department: He’s restructuring the IT infrastructure within the VA to facilitate access. For example, the VA just processed their first … Continue reading
Posted in Uncategorized
Leave a comment
Open Gov Summit: Aneesh Chopra
I’m here at the National Archives attending the Open Government Research and Development Summit, organized by the Office of Science and Technology Policy in the Whitehouse. It’s a series of panel discussions to address questions about the impact and future … Continue reading
Posted in Uncategorized
1 Comment
A case study in the need for open data and code: Forensic Bioinformatics
Here’s a vid of Keith Baggerly explaining his famous case study of why we need code and data to be made openly available in computational science: http://videolectures.net/cancerbioinformatics2010_baggerly_irrh. This is some of the discussion that resulted in the termination of clinical … Continue reading
Posted in Uncategorized
Leave a comment
Open peer review of science: a possibility
The Nature journal Molecular Systems Biology published an editorial “From Bench to Website” explaining their move to a transparent system of peer review. Anonymous referee reports, editorial decisions, and author responses are published alongside the final published paper. When this … Continue reading
Posted in Open Science, Peer Review, Reproducible Research, Technology
3 Comments
Chris Wiggins: Science is social
I had the pleasure of watching my friend and professor of applied physics and applied math Chris Wiggins give an excellent short talk at NYC’s social media week at Google. The video is available here: http://livestre.am/BUDx. Chris makes the often … Continue reading
Posted in Uncategorized
1 Comment
Science and Video: a roadmap
Once again I find myself in the position of having collected slides from talks, and having audio from the sessions. I need a simple way to pin these together so they form a coherent narrative and I need a common … Continue reading
Posted in Conferences, Open Science, Talks, Technology
10 Comments
My Symposium at the AAAS Annual Meeting: The Digitization of Science
Yesterday I held a symposium at the AAAS Annual Meeting in Washington DC, called “The Digitization of Science: Reproducibility and Interdisciplinary Knowledge Transfer,” that was intended to bring attention to how massive computation is changing the practice of science, particularly … Continue reading
Letter Re Software and Scientific Publications – Nature
Mark Gerstein and I penned a reaction to two pieces published in Nature News last October, “Publish your computer code: it is good enough,” by Nick Barnes and “Computational Science…. Error” by Zeeya Merali. Nature declined to publish our note … Continue reading
Startups Awash in Data: Quantitative Thinkers Needed
We know unix logs everything, which makes web-based data collection easy, in fact almost difficult not to do. As a result internet startups often find themselves gathering enormous amounts of data, for example site use patterns, click-streams, user demographics and … Continue reading
Posted in Software, Startups, Statistics, Technology
3 Comments